"

TL;DR: Shipping insurance is a math problem, not a security blanket. At 1-3% loss rate and typical insurance costs of 2-3% of declared value, insurance often costs more than self-insuring. The break-even point: insure when your loss rate exceeds insurance cost percentage. For most dropshippers, insuring standard orders is negative EV — but insuring high-value items (AOV > $100) and shipments to high-risk destinations makes financial sense. Veterans treat insurance as a selective tool, not a blanket policy.

"

The Insurance Question Every Dropshipper Asks

"Should I buy shipping insurance?"

The answer every beginner gives: "Yes, of course! What if packages get lost?"

The answer veterans give: "It depends on the math."

Insurance exists to transfer risk — you pay a small amount to avoid a potentially large loss. Whether that's a good deal depends entirely on the probability and cost of that loss versus the premium you're paying.

Let's do the math.

Shipping insurance typically costs 2-3% of declared value. Let's use 2.5% for our calculations.

The break-even question:

"

If insurance costs 2.5% of order value, is your loss/damage rate higher or lower than 2.5%?

"

If your loss rate is lower than 2.5%: Insurance costs more than losses. If your loss rate is higher than 2.5%: Insurance saves money.

INSURANCE BREAK-EVEN CALCULATION

100 orders at $50 average = $5,000 total revenue

Insurance cost (2.5%): $125

At 1% loss rate: 1 lost package = $50 loss
At 2% loss rate: 2 lost packages = $100 loss
At 2.5% loss rate: 2.5 lost packages = $125 loss (break-even)
At 3% loss rate: 3 lost packages = $150 loss
At 5% loss rate: 5 lost packages = $250 loss

Below 2.5% loss rate: Insurance loses you money
Above 2.5% loss rate: Insurance saves you money

For most reliable shipping routes (US, EU, established markets), loss rates are 1-2%. Insurance is often a losing bet.

Before deciding on insurance, know your numbers:

LOSS RATE CALCULATION

Past 3 months:
- Total packages shipped: ______
- Packages lost (never delivered): ______
- Packages damaged (customer refunded): ______
- Packages theft-claimed: ______

Total loss events: ______

Loss rate = (Total loss events / Total packages) × 100

Your loss rate: _____%

What counts as a "loss":

• Package genuinely lost (never arrived)
• Package damaged in transit (required refund)
• Package stolen after delivery (if you refund for this)

What doesn't count:

• Returns for buyer's remorse
• Quality issues with product
• Customer fraud (these need different solutions)

Scenario 1: High-Value Items

Insurance becomes more attractive as order value increases:

INSURANCE ROI BY ORDER VALUE

$30 order:
- Insurance cost (2.5%): $0.75
- Loss exposure: $30
- At 2% loss rate: Expected loss = $0.60
- Insurance vs self-insure: Insurance costs $0.15 MORE

$100 order:
- Insurance cost (2.5%): $2.50
- Loss exposure: $100
- At 2% loss rate: Expected loss = $2.00
- Insurance vs self-insure: Insurance costs $0.50 MORE

$200 order:
- Insurance cost (2.5%): $5.00
- Loss exposure: $200
- At 2% loss rate: Expected loss = $4.00
- Insurance vs self-insure: Insurance costs $1.00 MORE

But variance matters:
At $200 order value, 1 loss = $200 hit
At 100 orders/month, 2% loss = 2 orders = $400/month

The higher the order value, the more painful each individual loss.

Rule of thumb: Consider insurance for orders above $100 or when single losses meaningfully impact your operations.

Scenario 2: High-Risk Destinations

Some destinations have higher loss rates:

If you're shipping to destinations with loss rates exceeding your insurance cost percentage, insurance pays.

Scenario 3: Business-Critical Shipments

Some shipments matter more than others:

• High-value customers: Losing a repeat customer's package hurts more than the order value
• First orders from promising leads: Customer experience impacts lifetime value
• Fragile/unique items: Replacement cost or time exceeds insurance cost

Scenario 4: New Routes or Carriers

When you don't have data, insurance buys information:

• First month with new carrier? Insure everything.
• Entering new market? Insure until you have loss rate data.
• Testing new shipping method? Insure to establish baseline.

Once you have 3-6 months of data, you can make informed decisions.

Scenario 1: Low-Value, High-Volume

1000 orders/month at $25 AOV = $25,000 total

Insurance (2.5%): $625/month

At 1.5% actual loss rate:
- Expected losses: 15 packages × $25 = $375
- Insurance premium: $625
- Net cost of insurance: $250/month LOST

Over 12 months: $3,000 wasted on unnecessary insurance

For low-value items with reliable shipping, self-insure.

Scenario 2: Reliable Routes with History

If you have 12+ months of data showing consistent 1-2% loss rate on a route:

• You've established the baseline
• Insurance costs more than losses
• Self-insure and use savings to fund occasional losses

Scenario 3: Products You Can Replace Cheaply

If your COGS is 30% of selling price:

• Losing a $30 order costs you $9 in product
• Insurance costs $0.75 but covers $30
• Real exposure is replacement cost, not selling price

Exception: If you refund full price, your exposure is full price. If you only replace product, exposure is COGS.

Instead of paying insurance premiums, create a self-insurance fund:

SELF-INSURANCE APPROACH

Monthly shipping volume: 500 packages
AOV: $50
Expected loss rate: 2%

Monthly insurance cost (2.5%): $625

Self-insurance approach:
- Set aside 2% for loss fund: $500/month
- Fund covers expected losses
- Save $125/month vs insurance

After 12 months:
- Fund balance: ~$1,500 (contributions minus claims)
- Savings vs insurance: $1,500
- Total ahead: $3,000

Self-insurance works when:

• Loss rate is predictable
• Volume is sufficient to average out variance
• Cash flow can handle occasional bad months

Most veterans use selective insurance:

SELECTIVE INSURANCE STRATEGY

Insure:
- Orders > $100
- New/unproven shipping routes
- High-risk destinations
- Fragile items with high damage rate

Don't insure:
- Standard orders < $50
- Established routes with proven loss rates
- Replaceable items with low COGS

This captures the high-variance risk while not paying for insurance on losses you're comfortable absorbing.

Your fulfillment partner's approach to lost packages matters:

Questions to ask:

• What's your package loss rate on [destination]?
• Do you offer insurance? At what cost?
• What's your policy if a package is lost — refund, replacement, or nothing?
• Do you have carrier relationships that include loss protection?

What good partners provide:

• Data on loss rates by destination (helps you decide)
• Competitive insurance rates (volume discounts)
• Loss resolution support (handling claims)
• Sometimes: Carrier agreements that include basic loss coverage

One seller's approach: "My fulfillment partner shared their loss rate data by country. Turns out my route to Germany had 0.8% loss rate — insuring those packages was clearly wasting money. But the Israel route was 2.8%, so insurance made sense there. That destination-level data changed my whole approach."

The data your fulfillment partner can provide is often more valuable than generic insurance advice.

Insurance is only valuable if claims get paid:

Claim success factors:

• Documentation (tracking, photos, communication)
• Timing (claims filed promptly)
• Carrier investigation cooperation
• Policy terms (some exclude certain causes)

Common claim issues:

• "Delivered" but customer says not received (theft vs fraud ambiguity)
• Damage discovered after signing (often excluded)
• Missing documentation (tracking not updated correctly)

Practical reality: 20-30% of claims have complications. Factor this into your insurance ROI calculation — not all losses become successful claims.

INSURANCE DECISION TREE

1. Calculate your loss rate (past 3-6 months)
   → If < insurance cost %: Lean toward self-insure
   → If > insurance cost %: Lean toward insure
   → If unknown: Insure until you have data

2. Assess order value
   → AOV < $50: Self-insure unless loss rate is high
   → AOV $50-100: Case by case
   → AOV > $100: Consider insurance for variance protection

3. Evaluate destination risk
   → Established routes with history: Use your data
   → New routes: Insure until data exists
   → High-risk destinations: Insure

4. Consider business impact
   → High-value customer: Insure for relationship protection
   → Fragile/unique items: Insure
   → Easily replaceable: Self-insure

5. Implement hybrid approach
   → Insure high-risk, high-value
   → Self-insure low-risk, low-value
   → Review quarterly as data accumulates

---

What's a typical loss rate for dropshipping?

For established routes (US, EU) with reliable carriers: 1-2%. For emerging markets or newer routes: 2-4%. For high-risk destinations or during peak seasons: can exceed 5%. Your actual rate depends on carriers, destinations, and product type.

Should I insure every package or none?

Neither extreme is optimal for most businesses. Selective insurance — insuring high-value orders and high-risk routes while self-insuring the rest — maximizes value. The key is having data to make informed decisions.

How do I handle "delivered but not received" claims?

This is the most disputed category. Options: accept customer claim and refund (customer-friendly but abuse-prone), require police report (reduces fraud but adds friction), or have a maximum value policy for no-proof refunds. There's no perfect answer — it's a business decision about fraud tolerance vs customer experience.

Does my fulfillment partner's insurance cover my shipments?

Depends on your agreement. Some partners include basic coverage in their service; others offer it as add-on. Ask specifically what's covered, coverage limits, and claims process. Don't assume coverage exists without confirming.

Should I charge customers for shipping insurance?

Some stores offer optional insurance at checkout. The economics: if customers buy insurance at 3% and your cost is 2.5%, you profit 0.5%. But conversion may drop slightly. Test to see if your customers value the option.